"Inventory continues to be the most telling housing metric," appraiser Jonathan Miller told The Real Deal in October, after his third-quarter 2026 East End numbers came out. The headlines focused on prices. The Hamptons median sale price fell 6.3% year over year in the July to September quarter, to $1,875,000. Over the same three months, the North Fork median rose 19.6% to a record $1,249,500. Read quickly, those two numbers suggest the South Fork got cheaper while the North Fork got more expensive.
Inventory tells a different story, and for a second-home buyer weighing the two forks this winter, it's the more useful one. The Hamptons median fell because more of its sales landed between $1 million and $5 million, not because houses sold for less. Over the same quarter, most North Fork sales closed above $1 million. A buyer who moves north to spend less finds a fork with fewer listings and a higher share of bidding wars.
A lower median, without lower prices
Miller now produces his Hamptons and North Fork series with the Hamptons Real Estate Association, after 19 years of publishing it through a national brokerage. His explanation of the Hamptons decline turns on which homes sold. Sales between $1 million and $5 million, the range he calls the "Hamptons middle," made up 65.5% of all Hamptons sales in the third quarter, the third-highest share on record. All of the year-over-year sales growth came in that range. Sales above $5 million made up their smallest share of the market in five quarters. A median shifts when the mix of sales shifts, even if no individual house sells for less than its neighbor did a year earlier.
"That's why the overall prices dropped, not because prices are declining, but because there's less at the top and more in the middle," Miller told The Real Deal. The publication traced the thin supply at the top to a run of luxury deals at the end of 2025 and the start of 2026, which used up much of the high-end inventory. Before this quarter, the Hamptons median had posted a first-, second- or third-highest reading for six straight quarters.
That leaves a buyer with two practical facts. A typical Hamptons purchase this fall cost less than a typical purchase a year ago because the typical purchase was a smaller house. Meanwhile, North Fork closings have moved past the $1 million mark where the Hamptons middle begins.
The North Fork moved into seven figures
Six in ten North Fork sales in the third quarter closed above $1 million, the highest share on record. The average sale price was $1,625,795, the second-highest on record. Newsday reported that North Fork prices have nearly doubled since the third quarter of 2019, when the median was $629,000. Miller told the paper that the North Fork "is taking on the characteristics of the South Fork. Maybe the pricing isn't as high, but the housing market has evolved to perform like we've been seeing on the South Fork for the last decade."
The gap between the two medians has narrowed quickly. According to The Real Deal, the Hamptons median was about $2 million a year earlier. A 19.6% gain puts last year's North Fork median at roughly $1.04 million, so the spread between the forks was close to $1 million in the third quarter of 2025. This year it was about $625,000. Kristy Naddell, an associate broker at Douglas Elliman in Cutchogue, told Newsday that buyers have a hard time finding North Fork homes under $1 million that don't need extensive renovation.
A buyer who heads north from Hampton Bays or Westhampton to save money is therefore usually still shopping above $1 million, on a fork where The Real Deal reported that deals skewed toward the upper tier this quarter.
How supply and competition compare
The supply figures make the strongest case. This table puts the three Long Island markets in Miller's third-quarter 2026 release side by side, with listings counted at the end of September.
| Q3 2026 (July to September) | Hamptons | North Fork | Long Island, excluding East End |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $1,875,000, down 6.3% | $1,249,500, up 19.6% | $782,000, up 4.3% |
| Listing inventory | 973, down 22.5% | 144, up 1.4% | 5,053, up 3.4% |
| Competitive bidding | 5% of deals were bidding wars | 15% of deals were bidding wars | 62.2% sold above asking |
The 144 North Fork listings were 42.4% below the third-quarter decade average of 250. According to Newsday, 110 North Fork homes sold during the quarter, down 12%. That means the fork had only slightly more homes listed at the end of September than it had closed in the previous three months. Miller told The Real Deal that "the inventory situation is even tighter in the North Fork than in the Hamptons, even though Hamptons is really tight."
The Hamptons market is tight too, but its pressure looks different. Listings there fell to about 970 from roughly 1,260 a year earlier, the third straight quarterly decline. Miller said inventory is falling "almost three times faster" than sales, which makes the market feel quick on the ground. He added, "But it's not a boom." Only 5% of Hamptons deals involved a bidding war. At the high end, Hamptons luxury listings, which started at $6,625,000 in the quarter, were essentially flat year over year.
The mainland is the most competitive of the three. Excluding the East End, 62.2% of Long Island homes sold above asking in the third quarter, an all-time high that beat the 60.5% set a year earlier. Listings there were 35.8% below their third-quarter decade average. The mainland measure counts homes sold over asking rather than bidding wars, so it doesn't line up exactly with the East End figures. Still, every competition figure in the table rises as the median price falls.
What the quarter missed
The third-quarter figures cover sales that closed in July, August and September. According to Newsday, most of those deals went to contract over the summer, before mortgage rates climbed. The average 30-year fixed rate reached 7.4% in the week of October 9, the highest since 2023 and a full point above early July. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the rate at 7.11% for the week of November 12, down 0.07 percentage points from the week before. These rates are general market figures, not financial advice, and anyone financing a purchase should confirm their own terms with a lender.
On the North Fork, Naddell described the fall to Newsday this way: more price cuts, some owners taking homes off the market when they can't get their price, and seasonal buyers slower to commit. "It's very hard right now to keep deals together," she said. "We're seeing in some cases multiple offers with inspections and contracts going out and then buyers pull out last minute." Miller told the paper that higher rates are unlikely to persuade many owners that now is the time to sell.
Those accounts point to a winter in which the number of listings stays low on both forks while the terms of individual deals become easier to negotiate. On the North Fork, a buyer may still face multiple offers on a well-priced house. The same buyer may also find a seller who has already cut the price once and wants a contract that will hold. In the Hamptons, a 5% bidding-war rate and a large share of sales in the middle range give a buyer between $1 million and $5 million the most room on the East End to compare homes before making an offer.
In the third quarter, the North Fork's median was about $625,000 below the Hamptons median. It also had 144 listings against the Hamptons' 973, and bidding wars in 15% of deals against 5%. Our Long Island neighborhood guide and Southold real estate page cover both sides of the Peconic.
Questions buyers are asking this fall
Did Hamptons home prices fall in 2026? The Hamptons median fell 6.3% in the third quarter of 2026, to $1,875,000. Miller attributes the drop to a larger share of sales between $1 million and $5 million and fewer sales above $5 million, not to a broad decline in prices.
Is the North Fork still the lower-cost choice? The North Fork's median of $1,249,500 was still about $625,000 below the Hamptons median in the third quarter of 2026. Six in ten North Fork sales that quarter closed above $1 million, which puts most of that fork's sales above the $1 million line where the Hamptons middle begins.
Why are there so few homes for sale on the East End? Miller described the third quarter as a period of "maximum distortion because inventory remains chronically low." Supply on both forks and on the mainland is well below decade averages.
If you're weighing a house in Hampton Bays against one in Cutchogue or Southold this winter, talk with The Connelly Team about how this quarter's supply and competition figures apply to the homes on your list. If you own on the East End and want to know how your home fits into this market, request your free home valuation.